Last updated: November 15. 2013 4:08PM - 824 Views
Pastor Chad Johnson Russellville Baptist Church

Story Tools:

Font Size:

Social Media:

Dear Editor:

In the Nov. 12 issue of the newspaper, Geoffrey Butch challenged my statements about the first pope of Rome. I want to clarify my comments and also correct two things he said.

First of all, the reason I believe that Leo I (440-461) was the first pope is this quote from his own mouth, “Resistance to his authority was a sure way to hell.” He also advocated the death penalty for what he called heresy. This quote was taken from Halley’s Handbook on the Bible.

Some think Gregory I the Great was the first pope. He was pope from 590-604 AD. In O.C. Lamberts book Catholicism Against Itself, Volume II, (keep in mind, that these statements are taken from Catholic resources) said that pope Damascus (366-384 AD) was the first to call himself pope. He was also the first to appeal to Matthew 16:18 as his claim to be father of all churches descending from Peter.

So we see that Catholic and non-Catholic resources have different ideas of who was the first pope. The reason for this is that the concept of a supreme, infallible pope grew up gradually over the centuries as did the Catholic church itself.

Geoffrey Butcher said that Roman Catholic tradition traces the popes from St. Peter (32-67) and that Jesus said Peter would build his church.

This is a gross misreading of Matthew 16:18. Jesus did not say Peter would build His church, He said I will build my church.

Mr. Butcher also said that Peter’s name means rock. Peter comes from the Greek word petros. This word means small stone, a piece or fragment of a rock such as a man might throw.

The word rock in Matthew 16:18 comes from a different Greek word: petra, which means a large rock or mass of rock. It is obvious that the rock is referring to Jesus Christ, not Peter. All through the Bible when a word is needed to show a firm foundation, petra not petros is used.

I Corinthians 3:11 tells us Christ is the foundation. Peter himself is quick to say that Christ was the cornerstone and foundation of the church. I Peter 2:6-7

Paul was a prisoner in Rome in 61 AD. While in prison, Paul wrote many epistles in which he gives quite a complete list of fellow-workers in Rome and Peter’s name is not among them. Peter was not even in Rome until around 64 AD.

Pastor Chad Johnson

Russellville Baptist Church

All user comments are subject to our Terms of Service. Users may flag inappropriate comments.
comments powered by Disqus

Featured Businesses


Info Minute

Gas Prices

Russellville Gas Prices provided by GasBuddy.com